Scaffolding writing instruction to promote students’ autonomy in concept paper writing
https://doi.org/10.70228/CBJ2025072
Cite this article Read this article
ABSTRACT
In the context of academic writing, students’ capacity for independent writing is crucial to both their academic achievement and intellectual development. This study sought to explore the effectiveness of scaffolding writing instruction to promote students’ autonomy in concept paper writing. Employing an explanatory sequential mixed-method design, the study involved 30 introductions of a concept paper written by Grade 10 students as a pre-writing task and a post-writing task, as well as the rated survey questionnaires on autonomy before and after the intervention. A scaffolding writing intervention based on Vygotsky’s Psychosocial Constructivist Theory was conducted for two weeks. Using a set of inclusion and exclusion criteria, the three highest- and the three lowest-scoring students were invited to a one-on-one interview. Data were analyzed through mean and standard deviation. The findings reveal significant improvements in students’ learning autonomy in concept paper writing in the following areas: own learning goal, own learning plan, methodology, learning process, learning progression, strategy, and as a whole. Furthermore, findings from the interview reveal the following insights: enhanced content development and knowledge; improved writing structure and organization; strengthened grammatical accuracy and word choice; increased awareness of writing mechanics; increased confidence in writing; ability to self-correct and apply learned skills; and application beyond the classroom. Based on the key findings, an action plan for a professional development program on scaffolding writing instruction to promote students’ autonomy in concept paper writing for teaching and related teaching personnel was crafted.
Keywords: scaffolding writing instruction, students’ autonomy, concept paper writing, independent writing, scaffolding writing intervention
Volume 13 Issue 2, 2025 EDITION
Published 2025
Editor's Note
Dear Readers, Research becomes most meaningful when it helps us make sense of human experiences and respond thoughtfully to the needs of individuals, institutions, and communities. Across disciplines, it gives us an opportunity to revisit familiar concerns, ask better questions, and develop knowledge that can guide sound decisions. As an educator and researcher, I have always believed that scholarship should not remain within academic spaces alone. Its deeper value is realized when evidence leads to action and knowledge becomes a form of service. This spirit is clearly present in the studies featured in this issue of the Journal of Higher Education Research, and it continues the direction set by the previous issue, which emphasized research that reaches beyond the academy and contributes to meaningful change. Volume 13, Issue 2 brings together a rich multidisciplinary collection of studies on education, environmental technology, family engagement, human development, teacher resilience, governance, retirement, academic writing, and healthcare. Although the articles differ in focus and method, they are connected by a common concern: how people and institutions adapt, respond, and continue to innovate amid changing educational, social, technological, and professional contexts. The issue opens with the study of Apellido, Caberte, Divinagracia, Valenzuela, and Mateo, who examine the relationship among science process skills, academic engagement, learning management system use, and science achievement among junior high school students. Their work reminds us that science learning is shaped not only by content knowledge but also by the ways students participate, inquire, and engage with digital learning environments. The study points to the value of a more integrated approach to science instruction, one that brings these elements together in ways that better support learners. Innovation through research is also evident in the work of Bongcac and Pandan, who developed a rapid biochemical oxygen demand biosensor using a suspended microorganism system. By shortening BOD determination from the conventional five-day incubation period to a much faster reaction time, their study shows how scientific and engineering research can lead to practical tools for water and wastewater quality assessment. It is a reminder that work done in the laboratory can have direct value for environmental monitoring and public welfare. From environmental technology, the issue turns to the family and its essential role in education. De La Cruz and Dumagat investigate home- and school-based parental engagement in relation to children's holistic progress. Their findings show that parents and teachers may view engagement differently, particularly when comparing support at home with participation in school-related activities. More importantly, the study invites us to strengthen partnerships among families, schools, and communities so children may be supported in their intellectual, social-emotional, physical, and spiritual development. Human relationships and identity are viewed from another perspective in the study of Grijaldo and Lachica, who explore internalized homophobia, attachment styles, and parental attitudes among LGBTQ+ individuals. Their findings point to meaningful connections among attachment, parental behavior, and experiences of internalized stigma. By focusing on these psychological and social dimensions, the study deepens our understanding of why supportive relationships and affirming environments matter in promoting individual well-being. The importance of resilience and institutional support is likewise seen in the work of Baldevia and Ureta, who examine the post-pandemic experiences of public-school teachers living with chronic comorbidities. Through teachers' narratives, their study presents resilience not merely as a personal quality but as a process shaped by relationships, institutional conditions, and one's own sense of purpose. Their discussion of Lasallian values such as faith, service, and communion is especially meaningful, as it shows how these values can sustain educators while also calling attention to the need for humane and health-sensitive school policies. Research also helps us understand how public policy works in practice. In “Nudgistic,” Daya, De Sagun, Bullecer, and Rocina examine how behavioral nudges are embedded within local ordinances in selected Philippine local government units. Their findings suggest that nudging does not operate in a vacuum; its effectiveness depends on the social, spatial, and institutional realities of the communities where policies are implemented. The study offers a useful reminder that governance strategies must be attentive to context if they are to become truly responsive and effective. The continuing significance of the teaching profession beyond formal employment is beautifully captured in the study of Sambo and Jardenil, who explore the post-retirement experiences of Lasallian elementary teachers. The stories of their participants show that retirement does not necessarily mark the end of an educator's contribution. For many, it becomes a season of transition, renewed purpose, mentorship, community involvement, and continued service. Their findings remind us that the identity of an educator often extends beyond the classroom and beyond one's years of formal professional work. The development of learner independence is addressed by Mejorada-Reoja and Ausente, whose study examines scaffolding writing instruction as a way to promote students' autonomy in concept paper writing. Their findings show gains in several areas of independent learning and writing, including planning, organization, confidence, self-correction, and the ability to apply learned skills beyond a single classroom task. The study affirms the importance of instructional support that is carefully designed and gradually released, allowing students to take greater ownership of their learning. Finally, Gaqui, Fakat, Florendo, Flores, Franco, Garcia, Gimenez, Gonzales, and Dela Cruz bring the issue into the rapidly evolving field of telehealth by examining the experiences of Filipino nurses working in the United States. Their study highlights the cultural and communication challenges that may arise in virtual healthcare, including differences in language, accent, digital literacy, and patient expectations. At the same time, it shows the adaptability and cultural responsiveness of Filipino nurses as they provide care in technology-mediated settings. Their work points to the continuing need for cross-cultural training, institutional support, and clear communication strategies in an increasingly digital healthcare environment. Taken together, the studies in this issue show the breadth of contemporary research and its ability to connect fields that may at first seem far apart. From science classrooms and environmental biosensors to family relationships, teacher resilience, local governance, retirement, academic writing, and virtual healthcare, each article offers a different way of understanding how people and institutions respond to change. More than simply documenting problems, these studies help us interpret them, reconsider familiar practices, and identify evidence that can guide educational, technological, social, and institutional improvement. As Editor-in-Chief, I am grateful for the scholarship represented in Volume 13, Issue 2 and for the trust of the researchers who shared their work through the Journal of Higher Education Research. On behalf of the Editorial Board, I extend my sincere appreciation to our authors, peer reviewers, and editorial staff, under the leadership of Dr. Lota Largavista, Director of the Publication and Engagement Office, for their dedication to upholding the quality and integrity of the journal. I also thank our readers, whose continued engagement gives life and purpose to the dissemination of scholarly work. Every issue is the result of collective effort, and this one is no exception. As we continue to navigate changing educational landscapes, emerging technologies, evolving communities, and increasingly interconnected societies, may the research presented in this issue encourage deeper inquiry, meaningful collaboration, and a sustained commitment to knowledge that responds to real human and societal needs. May these studies not only be read but also discussed, questioned, applied, and used to inspire future investigations that advance education and the common good. Enjoy reading the current articles! Sincerely, JOVAL N. MARTINEZ Editor-in-Chief Journal of Higher Education Research University of St. La Salle
